Page 1 of 3
Re: Judged
Posted: Mon Jan 30, 2012 8:49 pm
by r.magnay
Pretty good Marty, couple of bits I stumbled over but I reckon by the time you have read it a few times you will iron them out! Good onya!
Re: Judged
Posted: Tue Jan 31, 2012 7:10 am
by Maureen K Clifford
What Zondrae said Marty, plus commas - '' '' etc will make a huge difference to it, but it is a ripper - well done.
Cheers
Maureen
Re: Judged
Posted: Tue Jan 31, 2012 8:17 am
by Neville Briggs
That sounds pretty good to me Marty.
I didn't find any stresses that seemed out of place.
And I argue that
scansion ( the analysis of metre ) is not a scientific mathematical formula, and it is not necessary for an exact plodding sameness of the metric structure all the way through. The bush poetry comp judges usually demand that sameness for written items, but it just isn't necessary in poetic writing. Although it is a good idea to get it " correct " first so you can learn how to vary it with some control.
I have two points though. In stanza 4 line 2.
You're stands for
you are. I think you need the possessive here which is
your, no apostrophe.
And stanza 5 line 2.
aint stands for
are not, so needs to be
ain't. with an apostrophe.
I don't think punctuation is necessarily a matter of right and wrong. What I do, is read out loud, where I make a slight pause, I put a comma. Where I think that the end of a sentence falls, I put a full stop, followed by a capital for a new sentence. It shouldn't get much more complicated than that.
I'm afraid I reckon that if a comma makes the difference between first and second in a poetry competition , then poetry competitions are a waste of time and effort.
Of course you won't take any notice of me, you'll listen to a red-headed sheila, but not me.

Re: Judged
Posted: Tue Jan 31, 2012 8:49 am
by Maureen K Clifford
I didn't know Julia wrote poetry as well Neville - we are truly blessed to have such a PM. We do live in the lucky country don't we?
Re: Judged
Posted: Tue Jan 31, 2012 9:28 am
by r.magnay
.....if todays results are anything to go by we might not have to worry about Juliar much longer....Kev might get his old job back...

Re: Judged
Posted: Tue Jan 31, 2012 9:46 am
by Maureen K Clifford
Well he is such a nice looking bloke I don't think that would be hard to take - just IMO of course and he never seemed to have the wardrobe malfunctions that Julia did.

Re: Judged-Edited- sliced . diced and munged back into shape
Posted: Tue Jan 31, 2012 2:36 pm
by Neville Briggs
You just keep out of the rain up there Maureen.

Re: Judged-Edited- sliced . diced and munged back into shape
Posted: Tue Jan 31, 2012 4:01 pm
by Zondrae
Goodonya Marty,
As I thought, the first time I heard you recite, you are a great story teller. You don't seem to have wasted many words. Every adjective has been thought of and the rhyming pattern is a real challenge. This one will be a keeper and I'm sure you will keep on polishing it 'til it shines like a new moon.
I will now and go and write 100 lines... 'you must spend more time on writing poetry'
.. but this would defeat it's purpose I suppose. ... (I'll go to my room again.)
Re: Judged-Edited- sliced . diced and munged back into shape
Posted: Tue Jan 31, 2012 8:32 pm
by Trisha Patterson
Hi Marty,
Nice story-line! Seems you have been inspired by your Tamworth trip!
Well done.
Trisha
Re: Judged-Edited- sliced . diced and munged back into shape
Posted: Wed Feb 01, 2012 2:12 pm
by Zondrae
...but one thing.
I was waiting for someone else to point to it.
Line 4, Stanza 1. ... what is with the 'ing'. It is not in the rhyming pattern or the metric pattern and isn't it wrong to have a soft ending to a line; three things that need to be addressed. (...Please advise if Ms Glenny gives a private lesson on same....)
if you simply have 'to cope' it may be better... or have you already done the fix?